As a new parent, you want every product you buy for your baby to offer the highest level of quality, safety, and comfort. These criteria are especially important when you shop for a mattress for your infant’s crib. With the wide variety of infant mattresses for sale today, how can you know that you are getting one that will keep your infant safe and comfortable each time you lay your baby down to sleep? You can choose the best crib mattress for your nursery and your budget by learning which ones top the market today.
Table of Contents
Crib Mattress Comparison
| Model | Material | Dimensions | Weight | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| sealy soybean foam-core crib mattress Editor's Choice | Soybean and Foam | 51.6x27.2x5 inches | 8.3 pounds | |
| Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress Editor's Budget Choice | Foam | 52x27.6x5 inches | 7 pounds | |
| colgate eco classica iii Editor's All-Natural Choice | Cotton and Foam | 51.7x27.5x6 inches | 9.4 pounds | |
| Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress | Vinyl and Foam | 52.5x27.5x5.5 inches | 7.8 pounds | |
| moonlight slumber little dreamer dual firmness all foam crib mattress | Nylon and Foam | 52x27.5x5 inches | 10.3 pounds | |
| Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Dual-Firmness | Organic Cotton | 52x27.8x6 inches | 20 pounds | |
| Sealy Soybean Serenity Organic Crib Mattress | Organic Cotton | 51.6x27.2x5 inches | 9.2 pounds | |
| Sealy Soybean Natural Dream Crib Mattress | Soybean, Cotton, and Foam | 51.6x27.2x5 inches | 9.2 pounds | |
| Newton Crib and Toddler Mattress | Recycled Polymer Fabric | 52x28x5.5 inches | 11 pounds | |
| My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress with Removable Waterproof Cover | Memory Foam and Vinyl | 51.6x27.2x5 inches | 11.6 pounds |
The Top 10 Best Crib Mattress Reviews 2018
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress
(Editor’s Choice) – Sealy remains one of the foremost names in the mattress industry, which is why its soybean foam-core crib mattress garners so much attention among expectant and new parents today. It is one of the best crib mattress choices that is made in part from natural soybeans grown by American farmers. Its foam center is covered with a visually appealing pearl embossed stain-resistant and waterproof cover that helps ensure its longevity and usefulness for years.
It also features lock-stitched corners that resist tearing, ripping, and stretching. The mattress is designed to breathe well so that your baby stays comfortable throughout the night without overheating or getting chilled. Finally, the Sealy soybean foam-core infant crib mattress comes in a size that is compatible with all standard baby beds and cribs. You can use it right away without having to stuff it in the crib or pack blankets around the sides to make it fit in the crib’s frame.
- Made from natural soybeans
- Pearl embossed cover for visual appeal
- Lock-stitching on the corner for longer use
- No removable cover
- Foam can sink after repeated use
Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress
(Editor’s Budget Choice) – Weighing just seven pounds, the Graco premium foam crib and toddler mattress fits both your infant’s crib and your household’s budget. This innovative and affordable crib mattress comes in shrink wrapped packaging for your convenience. You must wait 48 hours after unpacking it to allow it to expand to its full size and weight.
Once expanded and ready to use, this crib mattress will offer your baby all of the comfort and quality for a good night’s rest. It comes with a waterproof and stain-resistant cover that you can remove and put in the wash. It also is hypoallergenic so that your baby does not come into contact with dust, dander, and other allergens that could cause sneezing, coughing, and wheezing.
- Affordable price
- Convenient packaging
- Removable waterproof and stain-resistant washable cover
- Can fail to expand to full size if packaged poorly
- Can retain odors
- Prone to sinking if not turned or cared for properly
Colgate Eco Classica III Dual-Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress with Organic Cotton Cover
(Editor’s All-Natural Choice) – Colgate’s Eco Classica III dual-firmness eco-friendlier crib mattress is one of the premier organic crib mattresses available today. Made from all-natural materials like soybean oil and organic cotton, this mattress is guaranteed to be emission-free and is made to fit all standard U.S. baby beds and cribs.
It also comes with an organic cotton cover that is machine washable. It likewise has memory foam filling that is guaranteed to hold its shape and firmness, allowing you to use it for a toddler bed as your baby grows.
- Made from all-natural materials like soybean oils and organic cotton
- Memory foam center guaranteed to hold its shape
- Removable organic cotton cover
- Pricier than other crib mattresses for sale
- Plain appearance
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress
Made from hypoallergenic foam and vinyl, the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams white crib mattress is designed for your baby’s comfort and safety in mind. It meets all federal guidelines for fire resistance and also comes with a waterproof and stain-resistant cover that you can easily keep clean with mild soap and water. Likewise, it is priced affordably so that you can fit it easily in your budget.
The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams white crib mattress is also made to fit any standard U.S. crib and comes with innovative lock-stitch corners that resist excessive wear and tear. The mattress breathes well so your baby stays comfortable throughout the night without getting too hot or too cold. The mattress can also be used on a toddler bed, ensuring that you get your money’s worth out of your crib mattress investment.
- Affordable pricing
- Hypoallergenic materials
- Easy to clean
- Can grow mold if not kept clean
- Can sink if not turned regularly
- The length of the mattress may not fit some newer cribs
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness All Foam Crib Mattress
Moonlight Slumber’s Little Dreamer dual-firmness crib mattress makes every effort to keep your baby safe from allergens, viruses, and bacteria with its protective antimicrobial finish. This feature, combined with its medical foam center, ensures that your baby sleeps comfortably without inhaling germs and allergens that could make him or her sick.
Along with its innovative protective elements, the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer dual-firmness crib mattress is also made to last well beyond your newborn’s baby years. With its durable stitching and sturdy design, the mattress can be used on a toddler bed, ensuring that you get a good return on your investment.
- Antimicrobial protective finish
- Medical foam center for comfort
- High price tag
- Foam can sink and retain odors
Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Dual-Firmness
Naturepedic’s No Compromise organic cotton classic 150 seamless dual-firmness crib mattress is an all-natural crib mattress that is built to last for years. Featuring 150 individual coils under the organic cotton machine washable cover, the mattress also comes with durable side seams that resist excessive wear and tear. The cover itself is water and stain-resistant, making clean up simple and fast.
All of the materials used in the crib’s construction are certified organic and guaranteed to not emit harmful gases while your baby sleeps. It meets all federal guidelines for fire resistance and comes in a size that accommodates the frames of all U.S. made baby beds.
- 100 percent organic materials
- Fire, water, and stain-resistant
- Made to fit all domestic baby beds
- High price tag
- Flatter than other crib mattress options
Sealy Soybean Serenity Organic Crib Mattress
When you want an organic crib mattress that fits your budget easily, look no further than Sealy’s soybean Serenity organic crib mattress. This crib mattress is made with 100 percent all-natural materials like soybean oil and organic cotton. However, it comes with a price tag that is more realistic for working families to afford as well as quality that rivals any of the top dollar models on the market.
It also comes with a GREENGUARD certified technology cover that you can remove and wash and dry in your own machines. The crib mattress is easy to clean up and comes with a firm foam center that resists wear and tear, allowing you to use it as a toddler bed mattress later.
- GREENGUARD certified technology
- 100 percent all-natural materials
- Easy to keep clean
- Thinner than other crib mattresses
- Heavier than other mattresses made for cribs
Sealy Soybean Natural Dream Crib Mattress
Sealy makes another top quality crib mattress with its Natural Dream model. This mattress is made from all-natural soybean by-products and features PVC-free construction. It also is crafted from all-natural fibers that breathe well and help keep away allergens, fungus, and bacteria while your baby sleeps.
The mattress is also firm so that your baby avoids sinking into the center during naps and nightly sleeping. The seams are stitched tightly so that the mattress will wear well and be of use to you and your nursery for years to come.
- All-natural soybean oil construction
- Natural woven fibers enhance breathability
- Sturdy foam and stitched corner construction for durability
- Foam requires careful upkeep to avoid odors
- Higher priced than other Sealy crib mattress models
Newton Crib and Toddler Mattress
Newton touts its crib and toddler mattress as one that is better than organic with its all-natural, hypoallergenic construction. Made to fit any standard U.S. crib, this mattress is made from 100 percent all-natural cotton. It contains no vinyl, foam, or other man-made materials and is entirely recyclable when you are finished using it.
Even more, it features a woven attached cover for added visual appeal. The mattress reduces the risk of suffocation with its breathable woven fabrics and hypoallergenic finish that keeps away allergens, viruses, and bacteria.
- 100 percent organic cotton construction
- Hypoallergenic to keep away bacteria, viruses, and allergens
- Reduces the risk of suffocation
- More expensive than other crib mattresses
- Can grow mold and retain smells without proper upkeep
My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress with Removable Waterproof Cover
My First Mattress’s premium memory foam infant crib mattress is made for easy cleanup and maintenance. With its removable waterproof cover, it is designed to last for years, allowing you to use it later as your child’s toddler mattress.
This crib mattress also is made with a durable foam center that resists sinking and warping. It resists germs and allergens with its antimicrobial finish and also is made from materials that breathe well.
- Sturdy memory foam center
- Easy cleanup with its removable crib mattress cover
- Breathable, hypoallergenic finish
- Foam can retain odors from formula, diaper changes, and more
- Made from synthetic materials rather than organic or vegan-friendly materials
How to Choose the Best Crib Mattress
What exactly should go into your buying decision? Find the perfect crib mattress for your nursery by keeping these important criteria in mind while you shop.
Materials
One of the most important factors that should come into play when you shop for one involves from what materials the mattress is made. As you can tell from the reviews of the top crib mattress choices, these nursery fixtures are often made from materials that range from vinyl and foam to organic cotton.
When you shop for one for your baby’s bed, you should consider what kinds of materials align best with your budget and your baby’s needs. If your baby is yet to be born, you have no way of knowing if he or she will be allergic to synthetic materials and thus need a mattress made from organic cotton. Likewise, you have no way of knowing if your baby will sleep fine on synthetic materials, allowing you to spare your budget and invest in a mattress that could last longer.
Before you shop, you should research what materials are safest to use in your nursery as well as those that can give you the performance, safety, and peace of mind you need as a new parent. By having this information on hand before you make your selection, you can narrow your choices and select a mattress that will serve you and your baby well.
Price
Crib mattresses come in a wide range of prices from relatively inexpensive to astoundingly high dollar. As with most consumer goods, the top dollar price tag does not necessarily negate its quality. Likewise, it does not necessarily guarantee that it is the highest quality crib mattress on the market.
Most of the more expensive crib mattress choices available today are those made by lesser known companies or from materials that are 100 percent organic. The less expensive models are typically made from foam and vinyl.
Before you shop, you should have a definitive price range in mind so that you eliminate mattresses that are too expensive for you to buy. Your budget lets you select a mattress that offers you the highest quality at a price you can afford without having to sacrifice performance for money or vice versa.
Maintenance and Cleanliness
Another factor you should consider involves how much time you want to devote to the crib mattress’s upkeep. Do you plan on washing it down thoroughly each week or would you prefer instead to simply wipe up spills and messes with a damp cloth?
If you plan on devoting time to washing and drying the mattress regularly, you may prefer one that comes with a removable and washable cover or one that is made from organic cotton that requires the more intensive cleaning to avoid stains and odors. You may equate this bit of extra work with the sanitation needed to keep your baby safe from germs and allergens.
However, if you are not one to devote time to intensive cleaning or would prefer the convenience of wiping up messes with a cloth, you may prefer a vinyl and foam mattress. Vinyl is easy to keep clean and also resists stains and odors. It may be the ideal choice for working parents or parents who would prefer to make diaper changes and other cleanup times fast and easy.
You can also find mattresses covered in either cotton or vinyl that come with antimicrobial protective finishes. This finish saves you the work of having to sanitize and deep clean your baby’s mattress. It also helps your mattress last longer.
Future Use
When you shop for a mattress for your baby’s crib, you may want one that can also be used later as a toddler mattress. Toddler beds often feature the same dimensions as infant cribs. Rather than waste money on a separate mattress for a toddler bed, many parents prefer to use the crib mattress when their child outgrows the crib and can sleep in a toddler bed.
As you shop for a crib mattress, you may consider whether or not you want one that can be used as your child grows. If you want to use it for several years, you may choose one that is made from more durable and higher quality materials or one that comes with a lengthy warranty. These factors let you spend money on a crib mattress that will give you a good return on your investment as you continue to use it while your child transitions from the crib into a separate toddler bed.
Conclusion
A crib mattress is one of the most important purchases that you will make for your nursery. Find one that will serve your baby and your budget well with the details found in our crib mattress reviews and buyers guide.